We don't have to argue

From the Regional Director of Oceania

Fr Trevor Trotter Regional Director of Oceania

Over the last few weeks, I have been reading  "Let us Dream: the Path to a Better Future", which Pope Francis wrote with the help of Austin Ivereigh. It was only published in 2020, so it includes a lot of reflection by the Pope on the COVID crisis. He sees this time as a time of great possibilities. The crisis calls us to change and to dream of a new and better future.

There is much wisdom and learning packed into this easily read book. One key belief of Pope Francis is how we cope with the polarisation that we find in modern life. If you talk about politics, the question is, "Do you vote for the government or do you vote for the opposition?" In the Church, the question is, "Are you a conservative or are you a progressive?" 

In our arguments, we often take what is usually a highly complex situation and boil it down to just two positions. Is it black, or is it white? Polarisation is the default position for most of us.

The Pope says life is more complicated than that. 

Yes, you find people holding different opinions on matters, but these tensions are part of life. There are a couple of ways not to resolve the tension. 

One is to give in and so not hold the tension. Just give way to one side of the argument. Nothing new is learnt here and the discussion is not advanced any further. The other way that is not helpful is for the partners to stick to their guns and not move. Not only do they not move they do not even want to move. They are not open to discovering more truth. They are both static. There is no progress.

Pope Francis says that if the two sides listen to each other and hold the tension while remaining open to further learning, there will often be a breakthrough. 

We have forgotten in our arguments that we are not alone in our search for the truth. So often, the Holy Spirit's working in our lives is not factored into our search for the truth. The Holy Spirit is not listened to if we just give in or stick to the same old position we have always held. In Francis' language, the contrapositions have become contradictions. 

There is no breakthrough or to use another word from Francis; there is no 'overflow'. If the two sides of the argument are like two banks of the river, everything will continue. When the water rises and overflows the banks then something new is happening.  

How does this work out in reality? Does this describe what we have experienced?

In the book, the Pope gives an example which we are familiar with. During the Synod on the Family (October 2015) there were strong arguments about whether those Catholics who were divorced and remarried should be allowed to go to Communion. 

Some were for it and others against it. 

The tension was held, and an overflow came from Cardinal Schonborn when he pointed out that St Thomas Aquinas had said that "no general rule could apply in every situation". The Pope says in the book, "this allowed the synod to agree on the need for a case-by-case discernment. There was no need to change the Church's law, only how it was applied."  

He then says that this does not always work, and he refers to the Synod on the Amazon and the question of ordaining worthy married men. This issue was not resolved one way or the other. There was no overflow. Many other good things came out of the Synod but on this point, many were disappointed.

Really, we do not need to argue in the sense of just sticking to our guns and never giving in. If we find ourselves holding a different position from someone else, let us seek the Spirit's outcome. Let us listen attentively to the other person expecting that we will learn something from what is being said. Let us pay attention to what is happening within ourselves so that we are open to learning something new from this conversation. 

Unless we hear something different or learn something new, how will we grow in our knowledge of the truth? How will we grow in the love of God and the love of our neighbour?

Fr Trevor Trotter signature

Fr Trevor Trotter
Regional Director of Oceania
rdoceania@columban.org.au

Related links

2021 Columban Christmas Appeal

Support the Columban Christmas Appeal to help the poor, the exploited, and those affected by the Coronavirus pandemic around the world.