A Pope who is not afraid of open discussion and even dissent in the Church

Fr Noel Connolly SSCPope Francis is an unusual Pope who is bringing real change to the church by encouraging open discussion and refusing to silence dissent. In fact, he has said, “Open and fraternal debate makes theological and pastoral thought grow…. That doesn’t frighten me. What’s more, I look for it.” Many people would like to see him clarify matters and crack down on dissent but Francis is patient and wants people to speak their minds because he believes in a synodal church. He trusts that the Holy Spirit will guide us in the right direction.

Pope Francis talking to the Bishops before the first session of the Synod on the Family told them, “You need to say all that you feel with parrhesia” [boldly, candidly and without fear]. “And at the same time, you should listen with humility and accept with an open heart what your brothers say.”

Parrhesia or speaking boldly, listening humbly and always with an open trusting heart is Francis’ prescription for synodality and discernment. It is also collegial consensus building. Francis is not in a hurry. For him initiating processes is more important than forcing or arriving at quick decisions.

Here in Australia we are about to begin in earnest our process of preparation for the 2020 Plenary Council where we will discuss and discern the future of our church in Australia. Archbishop Coleridge, the President of the Bishops Commission for the Plenary Council, has assured us that everything is on the table and everyone is invited to be involved.

At the beginning of the Synod the Pope invited the bishops to speak up even if they thought he might not want to hear what they had to say. We are invited to speak boldly even if it may seem to be something the Bishops and priests might not want to hear. In fact, Vatican II in Lumen Gentium #37 tells us, we are “permitted and sometimes even obliged to express their opinion on those things which concern the good of the Church.” Pope Francis believes in the sensus fidelium or the sense of the faithful as an important part of the teaching authority of the church.

This is a new approach to what it means to be church. Lay people have not always been encouraged to speak up and we clergy have not always appreciated our responsibility to invite the “sensus fidelium” and to listen humbly. We all have much to learn and it may be a little messy and hurtful in the process. Consulting, speaking up, listening, discerning are all skills and they take practice to master. I imagine that the first time we speak boldly it may be clumsy and/or angry. It will probably be even more difficult for us to listen humbly, neither pointing a finger at, nor judging others but with open kind hearts trying to appreciate what the Spirit is saying through each of us.

It will require of us virtues like charity, open-mindedness, trust and patience. Charity to be kind, respect and listen to one another. Open-mindedness because “we cannot dialogue with people if we already know all the answers to their problems”. And above all trusting and patient because as Pope Francis has shown us, we need not be afraid of open and fraternal debate because that is how we will find what the Spirit wants. Most important things take time to emerge but if we give ourselves boldly, humbly and trustingly to the process, it will bear fruit at the right time. There may not be remarkable decisions but if we become a more synodal, consultative and participatory church, it will be worth it.

Fr Noel Connolly SSC is a lecturer in Missiology at both the Broken Bay Institute and the Catholic Institute of Sydney.

Related links

Comments (8)

    Oct 25, 2017 at 04:11 PM

    Thank you Fr. Noel for this heartening commentary on the attitude of Pope Francis. My only quibble is that in quoting from Lumen Gentium #37 you omitted the opening phrase, namely, "By reason of the knowledge, competence or pre-eminence which they have ". In my view a number of commentators on Church issues unfortunately speak out without regard to that important limitation . John H


  2. Dr Peter Mudge:
    Oct 25, 2017 at 06:18 PM

    Thanks Noel, you always give us food for thought, wisdom and true perspectives on life. Let's hope we can move with Francis and listen to those voices of the Holy Spirit with openness and parrhesia, as you point out. take care, Peter Mudge, colleague and interlocutor


  3. Henry Iglinski:
    Oct 25, 2017 at 07:30 PM

    “Many people would like to see him clarify matters…”. True. So why won’t he answer the Dubia?
    “Open and fraternal debate makes theological and pastoral thought grow…. That doesn’t frighten me. What’s more, I look for it.”
    So why did he refuse to dialogue with;
    - the Dubia Bishops
    - climate scientists who opposed his endorsement of the IPCC (political) global warming agenda?
    Maybe Pope Francis is applying his rule: “we cannot dialogue with people if we already know all the answers to their problems”.
    Being patient and hoping it will all work out is a bewildering response to immediate concerns by the flock. Allaying the concerns with dialogue would appear to be a better process.
    No response required.
    Regards, Henry Iglinski, 25-10-2017


    1. Mary McGinnis:
      Oct 31, 2017 at 12:26 PM

      I agree with you Henry and I know a lot of our congregation do too.
      Mary McGinnis


  4. Jill:
    Oct 25, 2017 at 11:10 PM

    Where is Jesus in this Church of Man?


  5. Daniel Dahdah:
    Oct 26, 2017 at 11:27 AM

    Wow. When people are given a voice, they feel less marginalised, even if decisions are not made in their favour. I'm all for allowing people the opportunity to be the church. The Holy Spirit is at work through his church. It would be great to have some pointers on how to do this well and showing respect when listening and speaking with Parrhesia! A great and welcomed article.


  6. Joseph Cincotta j:
    Oct 26, 2017 at 01:54 PM

    If I may humbly ask did Pope Francis say to vote yes on marriage equality?, because watching Q & A on the marriage debate I think that self centred priest a fr Brendan seem to indicate that the Pope would vote yes?, but I seem to read in the Archdiocese last issue the Pope said to vote no?. Were does this fit in with all you have spoken above?. Yes we need a leader but have we got one?.


  7. Gerry Rallos:
    Oct 27, 2017 at 09:20 AM

    Hope filled, uplifting article thanks Noel. Very happy to read that you will continue to write in Columban media. Thank you


Write a comment

Required fields are marked *

Allowed tags: <b><i><br>Add a new comment:*